On the eve of the budget, Construction Union UCATT has labelled the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) as not fit for purpose.
When CIS was revised in 2007 it became the responsibility of the employer to correctly register workers under the scheme. Employers were told that they would be fined if they wrongly recorded the employment status of workers.
Despite this the HMRC are unable to provide any information regarding how many companies have received fines for wrongly recording the employment status of construction workers.
The issue of correctly recording the employment status of construction workers is crucial, given the severe problem of false self-employment in the construction industry. The Great Payroll Scandal by Jamie Elliott, recently produced for UCATT, found that false self-employment was affecting 400,000 construction workers and was costing the Exchequer £1.9 billion a year in lost tax revenues.
When UCATT asked a Freedom of Information request on how many fines had been issued by HMRC for wrongly recording employment status the union was told: "HMRC holds information within the scope of your request but because our employer compliance information technology system is not configured to associate a penalty amount with a particular type of failure, I am unable to furnish this information to you."
When Natascha Engel Labour MP for North East Derbyshire asked a similar Parliamentary Question she was told: "The information is not available and could be provided only at disproportionate cost."
These answers differ from a previous parliamentary question which indicated the information was available. Former Labour MP Michael Clapham received an answer to his question regarding fines for wrongly recording employment status under CIS on 31st January 2008. The then Financial Secretary to the Treasury Jane Kennedy said: "At present, no instances have arisen where penalties have had to be imposed because of an incorrect declaration of employment status by a contractor."
On further investigation UCATT found that while the information on the HMRC website informed contractors that they needed to correctly register workers for the CIS scheme, the warning that they could suffer a "penalty" if they failed to do so was not prominent and no figure was placed on the potential sign of the fines.
Steve Murphy General Secretary of UCATT, said: "Once again it is clear that CIS is not fit for purpose. It would seem that companies can wilfully ignore the rules on employment status without penalty and HMRC is not pursuing them. False self-employment in construction is endemic in the industry yet HMRC is not taking the issue seriously."
(CD)
Construction News
19/03/2013
Union Labels CIS 'Not Fit For Purpose'

13/06/2025
A vital piece of Peak District railway infrastructure is set to receive a major upgrade this summer, as Network Rail announces a £7.5 million investment into one of Chapel Milton's iconic twin Victorian viaducts.
The 160-year-old, 15-arch structure plays a critical role in the UK's freight network,

13/06/2025
Morgan Sindall Construction has revealed plans to expand its operations in South Yorkshire, building on its strong delivery record in West Yorkshire and aligning with the goals of the newly launched Great North initiative.
Backed by northern regional mayors, the Great North initiative aims to unloc

13/06/2025
Construction has officially commenced on the new Children's Cancer Centre (CCC) at Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children (GOSH).
Led by long-term design partner BDP, the new centre is one of the most ambitious projects in GOSH's history. The firm is overseeing architecture, landscape, engineeri

13/06/2025
The developer behind the Redworthy Orchard scheme in Yatton has handed over the first homes to a local housing association as part of a wider plan to provide affordable housing in the area.
Persimmon Homes Severn Valley has transferred four new properties to Alliance Homes, a move set to ease press

13/06/2025
Wynne Construction has been awarded two major design and build contracts worth over £20 million by Adra to deliver nearly 100 new social homes across North Wales.
Construction is already underway at the first site on Berse Road, Wrexham, where Wynne began work in March on a £9 million, 47-home soci

13/06/2025
Great Places Housing Group has officially broken ground on its landmark £37 million LGBTQ+ majority Extra Care housing scheme in Whalley Range, marking the start of construction during Pride Month.
The scheme, hailed as the UK's first purpose-built Extra Care development of its kind, is being deliv

13/06/2025
Henry Boot PLC has announced that its property investment and development arm, HBD, has completed the sale of TWO45, a multi-let industrial-led business park in Skelmersdale, to a European real estate developer for £9.5 million.
Located on a 10-acre site just minutes from the M58 and M6 motorways,

13/06/2025
Clowes Developments has announced the successful letting of Unit 5A, a newly completed 27,000 sq ft industrial unit at Stud Brook Business Park, to Shawpak Ltd, a pioneering manufacturer of medical device packaging machinery.
Founded in Derby in 2013, Shawpak Ltd designs and produces a unique range

13/06/2025
The Hill Group and Legal & General (L&G) have announced a new partnership to deliver 200 affordable homes as part of the first phase of the £450 million City Centre South regeneration scheme in Coventry.
This marks the first time the two organisations have collaborated on a major residential devel

13/06/2025
The historic South Crofty tin mining project in Pool, Cornwall, is set to receive a significant boost after being awarded £4,190,500 through the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Good Growth Programme, marking the largest single private sector investment by the programme to date.
Delivered by Cornwall C